As the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops prepares to convene in Baltimore this November, the election of a new president and vice-president for the conference stands as a moment of no little consequence. In the current Church climate of eroding trust and unease within both the clergy and the laity, the need for leadership that inspires confidence and clarity has never felt more acute.

The statistical reality is sobering for anyone to read. Only 52 per cent of priests in America presently trust their own bishop, a figure that has declined from 63 per cent in 2001, and a mere 27 per cent say they trust the US bishops' conference as a whole. That is not a marginal deficit; it is a crisis of confidence that recalls the nadir of the US clerical abuse scandal which so profoundly scarred the Church in the early 2000s.