I begin with a question: how much, under the tutelage of its current chief Washington correspondent, Mark Mardell, will we be able to trust the BBC’s coverage of the forthcoming American election? I don’t just mean the usual thing one means about not trusting the BBC: that it has an inbuilt liberal bias. We all know that, and make allowances for it while continuing to rely on its news coverage. What I mean is, how competent will the coverage be? How much trouble will Mardell actually go to get his basic facts straight about the candidates, especially during the primary season now on us? Most of the current candidates are largely unknown here. Who on earth, for instance (the BBC should be able to tell us), is Rick Santorum, who has just come from nowhere to a virtual dead heat in Iowa (he lost by only 8 votes) with the much better-known and better funded Mitt Romney? Well, according to Mark Mardell, Santorum is an “evangelical Christian”. In BBC-speak, that means a Protestant Bible belt-type fundamentalist and extreme rightwinger (ie disbeliever in central government control of economic and social affairs). The only trouble is that Mardell is just wrong: Santorum is a straight down the line Roman Catholic. He may share certain views with American evangelicals: he’s anti-Obama, anti-gay marriage and anti-abortion, among other things. Well, so am I, but that doesn’t make me an evangelical Christian, Mr Mardell (oh, and don’t for heaven's sake riposte, dear reader, that all Catholics ought to be evangelicals, that the Church should evangelise, that in that sense there’s nothing wrong etc etc. We know exactly what the BBC means by an evangelical Christian). The details about Mr Santorum’s religious affiliation are right out there in the open. Just look him up in all the usual places. It is easy to discover from Wikipedia, for instance, that he usually attends a Latin Mass with his family (he has seven children, which ought to have given the game away even to the BBC) at St Catherine of Siena, Great Falls, Virginia, near Washington DC, a parish where it seems they take the sacraments seriously. They go in for regular adoration of the Blessed Sacrament; they announce on their website, under the heading “Sacrament of Holy Matrimony”, that “couples must contact a priest and begin preparation at least six months prior to the wedding” and that “living together before marriage is sinful and harmful to future marriage. Couples who are living together will be asked to live separately during the preparation time.” This policy no doubt has the support of the parish’s best-known parishioner. Santorum is clearly well known as a committed Catholic who has made it clear that he is 100 per cent in support of the Magisterium. He is involved in the affairs of his Church. He and his wife are, inter alia, a Knight and Dame of Magistral Grace of the Knights of Malta. I don’t know if he’s a member of Opus Dei, but he obviously supports it: in 2002 he spoke in Rome at a centenary celebration of the birth of St Josemaría Escrivá. In an interview with the National Catholic Reporter on that occasion, Santorum said (controversially it seems, though why I’m not sure) that the distinction between private religious conviction and public responsibility, espoused by President John F Kennedy, had caused "great harm in America". "All of us have heard people say [he declared] 'I privately am against abortion, homosexual marriage, stem cell research, cloning. But who am I to decide that it's not right for somebody else?' It sounds good, but it is the corruption of freedom of conscience." He had, specifically, been critical of Teddy Kennedy’s support for a “woman’s right to choose” abortion; and as a result was attacked by Kennedy himself, in the US Senate, for his bigotry. I have to say that he sounds to me like something of a good egg. He has “surged” to his present prominence from nowhere. Can he keep it up? According to the Guardian, which today accorded him a lengthy profile,
12:13 PM
Who is Rick Santorum, who nearly won the Iowa caucus? And can we trust the BBC to inform us about this or anything else in the US elections?
On Sundays Santorum goes to Mass in Latin; but the BBC Washington correspondent says he’s a Protestant. What else will he get wrong?
William Oddie
Already a subscriber? Sign in
5freearticles every month
Continue reading with a free account. No card needed.
- Five free articles every thirty days, on any device you sign in on
- The Catholic Herald newsletter, every morning
- Subscribe whenever you like for everything: every article and the magazine

subscribe to the catholic herald today
Our best content is exclusively available to our subscribers. Subscribe today and gain instant access to expert analysis, in-depth articles, and thought-provoking insights—anytime, anywhere. Don’t miss out on the conversations that matter most.
Subscribe












